Many artists (even very good, mature artists) seem to believe that “anime” is intrinsically childish or lesser than more “realistic” styles, and I for one would like to speak to you all about this, because I believe it creates bitterness between artists where there ought to be camaraderie, and keeps people from learning from any and all sources. Not to mention, when “realistic” artists condescend “anime” artists, it just causes the one being talked down to or insulted to mulishly refuse to explore anything other than their favorite manga styles, which is detrimental, or it may push them away from a style they used to enjoy, which is also detrimental.
Many artist choose to view artwork done in an “anime” style as invalid.
I think this is a childish point of view (having outgrown that mode of thought once I reached college) There is no such thing as an invalid mode of artistic creation. Artwork can be as “popular” as it wants to be and it will not be invalidated. The only thing that can make an artwork not art is if the artist refuses to develop his or her own style, leaning instead on the style of an artist they admire.
Taking inspiration from another artist is one thing, using their style because you fear to step outside of it is another.
When you claim that a style isn’t “art”, you alienate the artist and miss a learning oppourtunity. Whether you lean towards the East or the West, you can learn from any artist and any genre of art, and you will often be surprised by the sources of inspiration that shape your own work.
I think this is pretty much applicable to all other styles out there, too. And while I do understand that being a well-rounded artist makes you competent, I agree with all of this.
Apparently, it has already become a notion that “anime art” belong to the lower level of the hierarchy (I’m surprised that there’s even a hierarchy) and a lot of artists who practice this style get looked down upon. It’s sad because I know a lot of anime artists who can whip up something wonderful in a different style but specifically chose to draw animanga because it’s what they truly enjoy.
I’m probably saying this because I, too, draw predominantly in said style, and have experienced criticisms because of my preference, but my point is: Just do something you really want to do. And while you’re at it, try to keep an open mind, because to be honest, there are so many things exploring can teach you (I learned anatomy by drawing realistically, etc.). It’s just a matter of whether or not you want to grow as an artist. ;)
think this is pretty much applicable...other styles out there, too. And while
animation department at DJCAD would listen to this. :I